Poland’s Competition Watchdog Accuses Three Lublin Waste Firms of Bid Rigging

Poland’s competition watchdog UOKiK has charged three waste-management companies in Lublin with suspected bid rigging. The regulator alleges that Kom-Eko, Ekoland and Koma Lublin may have divided the city into territories and coordinated which districts they would bid for, potentially reducing competition for municipal waste collection and treatment contracts.

In some tenders, submitted prices exceeded the municipality’s budget by up to PLN 13 million. If the alleged anti-competitive agreement is proven, each company could face a fine of up to 10% of its annual turnover. The charges are allegations, not a final finding of wrongdoing.

Change in tender rules was intended to increase competition

In 2024, Lublin changed its procurement rules for municipal waste services. Previously, an individual company could bid in no more than three of the city’s seven districts. The revised arrangements allowed operators to submit bids across all seven areas.

The aim was to enable competition in areas previously served by different contractors. According to UOKiK, however, Kom-Eko and Koma Lublin may have agreed to bid only in districts where they were already active rather than competing for one another’s contracts.

Ekoland, a subsidiary of Kom-Eko, is also under investigation. The authority suspects the companies may have exchanged information about planned bids.

Some offers exceeded the city budget by PLN 9m and PLN 13m

The regulator is reviewing tenders in which bids exceeded the municipality’s planned spending. In two districts, the differences were PLN 9 million and PLN 13 million, prompting the city to cancel the procedures and issue new tenders.

UOKiK is also examining whether the two major operators coordinated their conduct during the repeated tenders. If a company knows that its main competitor will not bid for a contract, it may have less incentive to offer a competitive price.

UOKiK president Tomasz Chróstny said bidding is intended to ensure companies compete and present their best offers. He warned that if firms knew in advance they did not need to fear competition, the city and residents could lose out.

However, a bid exceeding a public budget does not by itself establish collusion. The regulator is assessing pricing alongside conduct and documents collected during searches.

Potential impact on local residents

Waste collection and treatment are significant expenses for municipal governments. Reduced competition can increase procurement costs, which may ultimately influence the fees charged to property owners.

UOKiK has not established a final loss to Lublin or calculated how much any alleged agreement may have raised residents’ bills. The differences between tender bids and budget estimates should not be presented as proven damages.

Regulator examines seized evidence

UOKiK says its allegations are supported by evidence secured during inspections and an analysis of tender procedures. The authority will now determine whether an unlawful arrangement restricting competition existed.

If an infringement is established, the regulator may impose a financial penalty of up to 10% of each company’s annual turnover. The companies retain the right to contest the allegations during the proceedings.

Source: Polish Office of Competition and Consumer Protection (UOKiK), announcement concerning Kom-Eko, Ekoland and Koma Lublin.

Original Polish article.

Tagi

Disclaimer: The information contained in this publication is provided for informational purposes only. It does not constitute financial or any other advice, is general in nature and is not addressed to any specific recipient. Before relying on this information for any purpose, independent advice should be sought. AI may support the editorial team’s work.

Selected categories